Szukaj

Trademark Exhaustion, Warranty Exclusions and Unauthorized Resellers

Under section 12(1) of the Trade Marks Act 1994, trademark rights are generally exhausted when genuine goods are placed on the UK or EEA market with the proprietor’s consent. However, section 12(2) permits opposition where legitimate reasons exist, including serious reputational damage or misleading commercial affiliation, provided the opposition is proportionate. Scholl’s Wellness Company Limited excludes unauthorized third-party sales from its manufacturer’s warranty and official after-sales support; describing these products as “New” without disclosing this limitation risks misleading customers about the benefits included. As recognized in AGA Rangemaster Group Ltd v UK Innovations Group Ltd [2024] EWHC 1727 (IPEC), paragraphs 22–23, these circumstances may provide legitimate grounds to oppose further dealings where the trademark’s reputation is prejudiced. Please investigate and take appropriate action, including removal of the listing where justified.